Josie's Pizza Hilltop Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Josie's Pizza Hilltop, a beloved gem nestled on W Broad St in Columbus, OH. Here, each dish tells a story steeped in tradition and flavor. Their menu offers a diverse range of options, from the savory Gut Buster specialty pizza, which has won acclaim for its bold flavors, to the classic Supreme that has customers reminiscing about the best pizzas of the 90s.
Josie's is renowned for its fresh ingredients, making every bite a delightful experience. The Italian subs, a family favorite, are perfect for a quick grab, boasting generous portions that leave diners satisfied. The warmth of owner Belinda shines through not only in her hospitality but also in the quality of the food.
- Location: 3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204
- Phone: +1 614-274-7822
Come join the generations of loyal patrons who have made Josie’s a community staple!
Pizza
Cheese Pizza (10" small)
Cheese Pizza (14" large)
One Item Pizza (10" small)
Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Pineapple, Jalapenos, Anchovies, Tomato, Cheese, Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Hamburger, Cheddar Cheese, Spicy Italian Sausage, Crispy Chicken, Hot Ham, Salami, Smoked Ham
One Item Pizza (14" large)
Toppings: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Banana Peppers, Black Olives, Green Olives, Ham, Pineapple, Jalapenos, Anchovies, Tomato, Cheese, Bacon, Grilled Chicken, Hamburger, Cheddar Cheese, Spicy Italian Sausage, Crispy Chicken, Hot Ham, Salami, Smoked Ham
Small Old Fashion (10" small)
Add some spice to your life with our spicy nickel-sized pepperoni served on top of the cheese. Our most popular specialty pizza!
Large Old Fashion (14" large)
Add some spice to your life with our spicy nickel-sized pepperoni served on top of the cheese. Our most popular specialty pizza!
Grilled Chicken "butter garlic sauce" (10" small)
Served "white" (garlic butter sauce instead of pizza sauce) with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing
Grilled Chicken "butter garlic sauce" (14" large)
Served "white" (garlic butter sauce instead of pizza sauce) with lettuce, tomato & ranch dressing
Combination (10" small)
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion & Green Peppers. An old Josie's tradition!
Combination (14" large)
Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onion & Green Peppers. An old Josie's tradition!
Supreme (10" small)
All the Way! Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, Ham & Extra Cheese
Supreme (14" large)
All the Way! Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, Ham & Extra Cheese
B.L.T. (10" small)
You guessed it! Lots of bacon, lettuce & tomato served with ranch dressing
B.L.T. (14" large)
You guessed it! Lots of bacon, lettuce & tomato served with ranch dressing
Gut Buster (10" small)
Regular Pepperoni, Old Fashion Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham, & Extra Cheese - not for the timid. A meat lover's paradise!
Gut Buster (14" large)
Regular Pepperoni, Old Fashion Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Ham, & Extra Cheese - not for the timid. A meat lover's paradise!
Veggie (10" small)
No meat here! Tomato, Onion, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, & Mushrooms
Veggie (14" large)
No meat here! Tomato, Onion, Green Peppers, Hot Peppers, Black Olives, & Mushrooms
Hawaiian (10" small)
In the mood for something different? Ham & Pineapple - give it a try!
Hawaiian (14" large)
In the mood for something different? Ham & Pineapple - give it a try!
Mexican (10" small)
Taco-Seasoned Hamburger, Jalapenos, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Sour Cream
Mexican (14" large)
Taco-Seasoned Hamburger, Jalapenos, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, & Sour Cream
Pizza Bowl
Gluten-free option! Pizza sauce, cheese & up to 3 toppings of your choice! Additional toppings, 1.00ea.
Butter Garlic Sauce
Specialty Pizzas
Calzones
What is a calzone? Cheese & your favorite topping wrapped inside our homemade dough, smother with butter, garlic, romano cheese & baked!
Owner favorite!!!
Small Calzone (additional toppings- small add .50 ea.)
Served with cheese plus any two toppings, served with marinara sauce for dipping
Large Calzone (additional toppings- large add 1.00 ea.)
Served with cheese plus any two toppings, served with marinara sauce for dipping
Chicken Nuggets
Chicken Wings (6)
A customer favorite! Deep fried with a little kick! Best in town!
Cheese Sticks (6)
French Fries
Wide-cut
Fried Mushrooms
Fried Cauliflower
Onion Rings
Mini Corn Dogs
Fried Broccoli & Cheese
Cheddar or Cream Poppers
Garlic Bread with Sauce
Garlic Bread with Cheese & Sauce
Appetizers & Side Items
9-Inch Submarines
Italian Sub
Salami, hot ham, provolone cheese & veggies (Add pepperoni - .50)
Super Sub
Sam as Italian but with double meats & cheese! (Add pepperoni - .50)
Stromboli (Double Stromboli - add 2.00)
Nine-inch seasoned meat patty with veggies. A long-time Josie's customer favorite!
"The Beast" Sub
Combine the Italian & Stromboli subs - a meat lover's dream!
Meatball Sub
Three meatballs, spaghetti sauce & provolone cheese
Crispy Chicken Sub
Fried chicken filets with provolone cheese & veggies
Ham & Cheese Sub
Ham, provolone cheese & veggies
Fish Sub
Fried fish patty, American cheese, veggies & tartar sauce
Grilled Chicken Sub
Chicken, provolone cheese, and veggies
Veggie Sub (For our vegetarian friends!)
Provolone cheese, American cheese, mushrooms, onions, green peppers, hot peppers, black olives, lettuce & tomato
Pizza Sub
Mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, & pizza sauce baked in oven. (Additional items - .50)
*Add bacon to any sub for just 2.00
Garden Salad (small in a cup)
Garden mix with tomato
Garen Salad (large)
Garden mix with tomato
Chef Salad (small)
Ham, salami, mozzarella cheese, tomato & pepperoni
Chef Salad (large)
Ham, salami, mozzarella cheese, tomato & pepperoni
Grilled Chicken Salad (small)
Grilled chicken, tomato & cheese
Grilled Chicken Salad (large)
Grilled chicken, tomato & cheese
Crispy Chicken Salad (small)
Deep fried chicken strips, bacon, tomato & cheese
Crispy Chicken Salad (large)
Deep fried chicken strips, bacon, tomato & cheese
Crispy Pepperoni Salad (small)
Tomato, hot peppers, black olives, mozzarella cheese & fried pepperoni
Crispy Pepperoni Salad
Tomato, hot peppers, black olives, mozzarella cheese & fried pepperoni
* Large salads include 3 dressings, small salads include 2 dressings. Extra packets of dressings - add .75 ea.
Dressings: Golden Italian, House Italian, Light Italian, Fat Free California French, Thousand Island, Dijon Honey Mustard (call for availability)
Salads
Dinners
* All dinners served with side salad and dinner roll
Spaghetti
Lasagna
Fish Dinner
2 pieces of cod, served with French fries
Shrimp Dinner
21 Pieces of fried shrimp, served with French fries
Chicken Wing
6 chicken wings served with French fries
Hamburger
Served with pickle, lettuce & onion (Make it a double for just 1.50 more.)
Cheeseburger
Served with American cheese, pickle, lettuce & onion. (Make it a double for just 1.50 more.)
Meatball Sandwich
Served with provolone cheese
Chicken Sandwich
Served with provolone cheese & veggies
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Served with provolone cheese & veggies
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Served with provolone cheese & veggies
* Add bacon to any sandwich for 1.50.
Sandwiches
TIDBITS:
Hours & prices subject to change without notice. Delivery ends 45 minutes before closing.
Minimum delivery 6.00, excluding soda pop. 3.00 delivery charge. Ask about our gluten-free pizza crust (based on availability) or try our pizza bowl as a gluten-free option!. 1 large flap 2 small flaps (no exceptions).