Welcome to Josie's Pizza Hilltop
Nestled in Columbus, Ohio, Josie's Pizza Hilltop has garnered a loyal following for its delectable offerings and warm atmosphere. With rave reviews from customers spanning generations, this beloved establishment is known for its mouth-watering tavern-style pizzas, including the award-winning Gut Buster. Diners praise the freshness of the ingredients and the remarkable flavors, making it a go-to for both casual meals and special occasions. The welcoming owner adds a personal touch to the dining experience, ensuring guests feel valued. A visit to Josie's is not just about pizza; it's about savoring fond memories and creating new ones over incredible food.
-
3205 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43204, United States Hotline: +1 614-274-7822
Welcome to the delightful world of Josie's Pizza Hilltop, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Columbus, Ohio. Located at 3205 W Broad St, Josie's has become a cherished spot for pizza enthusiasts of all ages. With a legacy of outstanding flavors and heartfelt service, this restaurant brings a slice of Italy right to your plate.
Customers heap praise on the incredible variety of offerings, with standout dishes like the Gut Buster, which recently took home the crown in a pizza tasting contest. This specialty pizza showcases the artistry behind Josie's culinary creations, promising a mouthwatering experience that leaves diners raving. Taylor Fout sums up the vibes perfectly, confessing that they were “hooked” after their very first bite!
Beyond just pizza, Josie’s presents a scrumptious menu filled with options that cater to every taste. From the classic Italian sub that has been a family favorite for generations to the highly recommended Supreme Pizza, there’s something for everyone. Amanda Elliott reminisces about savoring “the best pizza I've had since the 90s,” which speaks volumes about the flavors that transcend time.
What really sets Josie's apart is its community-centric ethos. With a team that genuinely cares for its customers, the staff, especially the owner, have been highlighted for their warm hospitality. The experiences shared by customers like molasess73 k confirm that any hiccups in service are met with swift and friendly resolutions, ensuring loyalty from those who come back time and again. It’s no wonder that Colleen Knapp, who has been visiting for decades, still considers Josie's unmatched in flavor after all these years.
As you embark on your culinary adventure here, be prepared to indulge in top-quality, fresh ingredients that evoke nostalgia and ignite your taste buds. Whether you’re a pizza aficionado or a first-time visitor, Josie’s Pizza Hilltop is more than just a meal; it’s an experience steeped in love, tradition, and exceptional flavors. Do yourself a favor and swing by to taste the magic that has kept this restaurant a pillar of the community!
For more details or to place an order, give them a call at +1 614-274-7822. Your taste buds will thank you!
FIRST TIME having this, we are hooked. We are offended at ourself we haven’t tried this earlier! This is amazing pizza!
3 Generations of good eating. My daughters 1st time eating a whole Italian sub no onions. And it's a must everytime we on the west side. The owner she is amazing so polite. And respectful I adore her.
A huge Thank you to Belinda for the mouth watering Gut buster and The savory peperoni pizza that we used for our pizza tasting contest. The Gut Buster won the specialty pizza category. I myself found this one to be ah-maz-ing as I had never tried it myself. Thank you again and I will be back to get another Gut Buster!!
First time trying this place and let me tell ya the Supreme is really good. Best pizza I've had since the 90s probably. The 2 of us demolished a LG. Definitely will be getting a pizza from here whenever I'm at the Hollywood casino!! Thank you!
I wrote a bad review over the Weekend. Ordered a a Pizza got overcharged. The lady working Saturday night couldn't help me. I called back today talked to the Manager. She was very friendly fixed the problem immediately and refunded me for the overcharge. Also The overcharge was not intentional . Been eating here all my life. Happy the issue was solved.
A typical hole in the wall. Incredible food, incredible prices. Tavern-style pizza, but fresh and great tasting. What turned from a common advertisement of a free large pizza just for being new to the neighborhood turned into our future pizza joint. I really love this place.
Best pizza and Salad I've ever had. Everything is so fresh. I am willing to come from Canal Winchester
I've been eating at Josie's pizza since I was six years old. We lived 60 miles away, but almost every weekend, we would drive from the farm to the bottoms. The original location is closed, but family members opened up a new location a bit closer to downtown by a block or two. I'm now 65 and I still have yet to find a pizza better than Josie's!